Just a Bad Dream // 154

 

This episode is available early and ad-free exclusively on Invisible Choir + on Apple Podcasts and Patreon. It is scheduled for free ad-supported release on Sunday, September 14th, 2025.


18-year old Kolton Shearer was a recent high school graduate with big dreams for his future. In July of  2016, he had just returned home from college to Clay County, Florida, and was looking forward to spending time with friends. But a fun evening out suddenly turned into a nightmare, when a shocking attack left one person dead and another gravely wounded. As police interviewed witnesses, they zeroed in on a young woman who presented herself as an innocent bystander. But was she? 

Written by Jessamyn Ansary, Edited & Engineered by Scott Ecklein, and Executive Produced by Michael Ojibway.

Visit Invisible Choir on the web: 

Written/Audio Sources: 

  1. FOIA Request: Alexandra Schreffler Interrogation

  2. FOIA Request: Jordan Coleman Interrogation

  3. FOIA Request: Incident reports

  4. Clay Today Online

  5. Obituary

  6. The Nieves Law Firm

  7. Ansara Law Firm

  8. Interrogation article

  9. Side effects of adrenaline

  10. Friend talks about the night of Teen’s death

  11. Brownstein Law

  12. 3 Charged

  13. Wikipedia: Reid Technique

  14. The REID 9 steps of Interrogation

  15. Crunching the numbers

  16. OLR Interrogation Techniques

  17. NPR article

  18. Robert Malov Law

  19. Final suspect gets 15 years

  20. Armed Robbery - Hanlon law

  21. Hornsby law

  22. Woman Sentenced

  23. Inmate page

  24. Change.org petition

  25. Vigil Scheduled

  26. Slain teen remembered

  27. Two men plead guilty


Music & Sound Effect Sources

  • Opening Track: “Unfolding Horizon” by Amber Glow

  • Closing Track: “pärlemor” by bomull


Music & Sound Effect Sources

All music and sound effects used with express permission under unlimited blanket license authority from Epidemic Sound ® and SoundStripe ®.  Individual sources are available via request at info@invisiblechoir.com