The Treehouse // 161

 

This episode is available early and ad-free on Invisible Choir + on Apple Podcasts and Patreon, and is scheduled for regular/free release on Sunday, January 4th, 2026.


On a November night in Key West, FL in 2017, friends Paula and Roger were hanging out and partying in Paula’s makeshift home nicknamed “The Treehouse.” Without warning, they were suddenly accosted by two masked men, leading to a tragic killing. The subsequent police investigation quickly mutated into a convoluted conspiracy involving drugs, coercion, and corruption. The result: a lone defendant representing himself in court swearing that he had been falsely accused - a man Paula swore was not one of her attackers…

Special thanks to Franklin Tyrone Tucker for his willingness to speak with us for this episode. Written by Sam Foster, Edited and Engineered by Scott Ecklein, and Executive Produced by Michael Ojibway.

Visit Invisible Choir on the web: 

Written/Audio Sources: 

  1. Franklin Tyrone Tucker Exclusive Interview

  2. WATCH LIVE: Treehouse Murder Trial — FL v. Franklin Tyrone Tucker — Day One

  3. WATCH LIVE: Treehouse Murder Trial — FL v. Franklin Tyrone Tucker — Day Two

  4. WATCH LIVE: Treehouse Murder Trial — FL v. Franklin Tyrone Tucker — Day Three

  5. WATCH LIVE: Treehouse Murder Trial — FL v. Franklin Tyrone Tucker — Day Four

  6. WATCH LIVE: Treehouse Murder Trial — FL v. Franklin Tyrone Tucker — Day Five

  7. WATCH: Treehouse Murder Trial — FL v Franklin Tyrone Tucker — Day Six

  8. WATCH LIVE: Treehouse Murder Trial — FL v. Franklin Tyrone Tucker — Day Seven

  9. WATCH LIVE: Treehouse Murder Trial — FL v. Franklin Tyrone Tucker — Day Eight

  10. WATCH LIVE: Treehouse Murder Trial — FL v. Franklin Tyrone Tucker — Day Nine

  11. VERDICT WATCH: Treehouse Murder Trial — FL v. Franklin Tyrone Tucker — Day 10

  12. Florida Man's Nightmare: The Shocking Interrogation & Wrongful Arrest

  13. The Treehouse Murder | Rory “Detroit” Wilson Interrogation

  14. Veteran LIES & CRIES!! Interrogation: The TREEHOUSE police interview - True Crime Documentary!

  15. A Florida Keys judge keeps ‘tree house murder’ suspect in jail for now

  16. Lawsuit filed by fired Monroe County Sheriff's Office deputy is dismissed | Local News | keysnews.com

  17. The robbery of a treehouse turns deadly with the slashing of a good Samaritan

  18. We were able to secure an interview with Paula Belomonte. Belmonte is a surviving victim of the Treehouse murder. Belmonte wanted to go on the record to state her side of the story, and how she knows that Tyrone Tucker is innocent. This story is crazy, and listening to Belmonte recount it in her own words, does something that reading through hundreds of pages just can never do. Stay tuned as we have more coming still. Doc Justice | True Homestead | Facebook

  19. TREEHOUSE MURDER: Lead Detective Claims His Boss Coached Witnesses and Fabricated Evidence - Key West The Newspaper

  20. Treehouse Murder Gets National Attention - Key West The Newspaper 

  21. Full Deposition of Matthew Pitcher Transcript 

  22. FL v. Franklin Tyrone Tucker: Treehouse Murder Trial | Court TV

  23. Chapter 777 Section 011 - 2011 Florida Statutes

  24. A Florida Keys judge keeps ‘tree house murder’ suspect in jail for now

  25. Franklin Tyrone tucker is accused of the tree house murders in Florida,Now on trial Jan 11th..2024

  26. Franklin Tyrone Tucker Facebook Page

  27. JURY HUNG IN 'TREE HOUSE' MURDER CASE | | keysnews.com

  28. Lawsuit filed by fired Monroe County Sheriff's Office deputy is dismissed | Local News | keysnews.com

  29. The robbery of a treehouse turns deadly with the slashing of a good Samaritan

  30. Man Arrested in Fatal Florida Keys Stabbing

  31. Woman with slashed throat IDs Florida murder suspect  

  32. A Florida sheriff office's captain told a deputy to act like a 'white supremacist' and a 'Nazi' when stopping a black murder suspect

  33. Fantasy Fest

  34. Reid Technique - an overview | ScienceDirect Topics

  35. John E. Reid and Associates, Inc. 

  36. False Confessions: The Issues to be Considered | John E. Reid and Associates, Inc.

  37. The Reid Technique - About the Company

  38. False confessions by Saul M. Kassin

  39. INTERROGATION TECHNIQUES

  40. Keys sheriff fires high-ranking detective over telling a deputy ‘to be the neo-Nazi’

  41. Franklin 'Ty' Tucker released from jail after pleading no contest to robbery | Court TV

  42. Inside Crossfit Founder Lauren Jenai’s Romance With Childhood Friend, Who's Also An Accused Killer | Oxygen

  43. Crossfit Founder Bailed Out Her High School Crush

  44. Lauren Jenai Facebook Page

  45. Post from Truth Behind The Treehouse - YouTube

  46. Obituary | Paula Jean LeBresco Belmonte of Key West, Florida | Dean-Lopez Funeral Home

  47. Rory Wilson v. The State of Florida

  48. CrossFit’s Lauren Jenai living apart from husband who’s under house arrest

  49. Minds of Madness - Matthew Bonnett - Instagram

  50. John Travis Johnson Arrest Record - Rockwall, TX   

  51. Census Data - Stock Island, Florida  

  52. Keys Overnight Temporary Shelter (Kots) - 5537 College Road, Key West, FL                                       


Music & Sound Effect Sources

  • Opening Track: “Soma Theatre of Distorted Love” by pär

  • Closing Tracks: “Subconscious” by Nihoni; “Death Whistle OUTRO” by Michael Ojibway

All music and sound effects used with express permission under unlimited blanket license authority from Epidemic Sound ® and SoundStripe ®. Individual sources are available via request at info@invisiblechoir.com